Paraguay's 5.8% Growth Masks Fiscal Cracks and Energy Crisis
Share this digest
Paraguay is navigating the most turbulent institutional and macroeconomic moment of the Peña era, with growth that defies regional averages but whose fiscal, energy, and regulatory fissures demand immediate attention.
The Banco Central del Paraguay reports that the economy expanded 5.8% in the first quarter of the year, accelerating in April to a 5.1% cumulative rate over the first four months, driven by agriculture, industry, and services. The soy complex contributed USD 2.492 billion through May, while family remittances total USD 732 million annually, consolidating hard-currency flows that sustain domestic consumption, which grew 4.8% in the first quarter according to the BCP. Optimism among economic agents points to full-year growth near 5%, with some economists suggesting it could exceed that threshold. The International Monetary Fund, for its part, adjusted its projection to 4.4%, though it acknowledged the solidity of Paraguay's performance and dispatched a technical mission to review the macroprudential measures currently in force — a signal of scrutiny that should not be read as merely ceremonial.
Country risk stands at 104 basis points, a level that places Paraguay among the most competitive in the region in terms of sovereign credit perception. The local Treasury bond market reaches some USD 1.2 billion, and the government is managing more than USD 1.6 billion in additional external credit lines. However, public debt grew by USD 1.333 billion in just four months, interest service jumped 16.8% year-on-year, and the Caja Fiscal deficit reached USD 182 million over five months. The MEF acknowledges a fiscal deficit equivalent to 0.9% of GDP through May, a figure ABC Color disputes, noting that President Peña omitted from his management report both the debt dynamics and the so-called "war economy." Debt owed to the construction sector exceeds USD 300 million in outstanding principal and interest, and MSMEs are pressing the state with a question that captures the fiscal paradox of the moment: if collections are growing, why aren't the bills being paid?
On the tax front, the Dirección Nacional de Ingresos Tributarios — the result of the merger between the SubsecretarÃa de Tributación and the Dirección de Aduanas — faces its first credibility test. Its head, Óscar Orué, has pledged to raise the tax burden from 10% to 12% of GDP and increase revenue by roughly USD 400 million annually. But the day was marked by reports of failures in the SIARA system on its filing deadline, a troubling signal about the operational capacity of the new agency. In parallel, customs revenue posted a decline that the DNIT itself had to explain publicly.
The labor agenda took effect with the minimum wage adjustment, a decision the Executive pushed through amid controversy. The Asociación Industrial y Comercial del Paraguay, Asimcopar, warned that the increase lacks technical grounding and deters investment, while economists cautioned about a limited impact on real purchasing power and greater pressure on labor informality and prices. MSMEs, in turn, criticized what they called a "populist holiday" decreed by Peña, estimating losses in the millions. In the financial sector, the BCP ordered a new reduction in credit and debit card payment commissions, a measure taking effect today that seeks to broaden financial inclusion in a banking system where the consumer credit stock continues to expand.
The energy sector is the sharpest pressure point of the moment. The London Stock Exchange suspended Atome Energy's shares after the leak of an internal communication from the Administración Nacional de Electricidad rejecting the project, which would imply an estimated cost of USD 1.6 billion for Paraguayan consumers. ANDE, which is simultaneously negotiating a tariff adjustment of uncertain outcome, sees its governance compromised just as the Peña administration was touting the Yguazú Digital agreement as a management achievement. The fishing sector in Ayolas, meanwhile, threatened new protests over non-compliance by the Entidad Binacional Yacyretá, adding strain to the state's relationship with riverside communities dependent on the binational hydroelectric entities. Petropar, for its part, cut the price of regular diesel without touching gasoline, responding to a price escalation in which private operators had matched their rates to those of the state-owned company — with Petropar's president offering no clarity on when the full pricing picture will normalize.
On trade and integration, Senacsa indicated that Paraguay has little to lose if the Mercosur-European Union agreement fails to include favorable beef quotas, while the regional bloc assessed the impact of external shocks and agreed on a new study of the agricultural sector. The country's economic openness stands 27 percentage points above the Latin America and Caribbean average, a differential the government showcases as an asset for attracting investment, though ABC Color noted that Peña omits from that same narrative the bureaucratic hurdles and legal uncertainty that stall the materialization of announced capital.
What investors should monitor in the coming weeks is both multiple and convergent: the resolution of the tariff conflict between ANDE and Atome and its implications for the country's energy security; the pace of passage of the Caja Fiscal reform, which the president of the Chamber of Deputies, Adriana Villamayor Alliana, promised for this week with modifications; the trajectory of the fiscal deficit in a second half that combines higher social spending — USD 2.590 billion executed through May — with a more demanding debt calendar; and the operational credibility of the DNIT, whose first systemic crisis arrived on the least opportune day possible.